Trick or treat introduced the world to the creepiest kid this side of Chucky: Sam. Wearing a burlap sack and an orange jumpsuit, Sam shows up whenever someone breaks a Halloween tradition. Since then, he has become an icon of modern horror, and there are sure to be plenty of burlap sacks and orange pajamas this Halloween.

The film had a very limited theatrical release in 2007, mostly relegated to festivals. Two years later, it was available direct-to-video, which doesn’t usually bode well for movies, but over the years, it’s achieved cult status. With that rise in popularity, it has become a staple of horror cosplayers everywhere, and there have been action figures, comics, and even a section of Universal Studios’ Halloween Horror Nights. In the last 10 years, it was reported that a sequel was in the works, but that talk fell through.